Documents menu
Date: Sat, 9 Dec 1995 16:56:23 GMT-5
Sender: H-NET List for African History <H-AFRICA@msu.edu<
Subject: REPLY: Readings for African Slavery Course
Readings for African Slavery Course
A dialog from H-Africa list 7 December 1995
Date sent: Thu, 07 Dec 1995
From: David Lee Schoenbrun, University of Georgia
<DSCHOENB@uga.cc.uga.edu>
For students who will use Meillassoux's Anthropology of
Slavery, please also have a look at Joseph Miller's long
review in the IJAHS 22, 3 (1989), 473-95, and the excellent
review article by Glassman in Slavery and Abolition [the
current number, I believe, or the penultimate one]. Both
make very different but also very pointed critiques.
Date sent: Mon, 4 Dec 1995
From: Paul Nugent, University of Edinburgh
<Paul.Nugent@ed.ac.uk>
Although both texts are dense, I have found it valuable to
discuss the introduction to Miers and Kopytoff, Slavery in
Africa, alongside Meillassoux's The Anthropology of
Slavery (or alternatively his contribution to Robertson
And Klein, Women and Slavery in Africa).
They start from very different assumptions and, in my
recent experience, this in itself provokes fruitful debate
amongst students. By the end, the penny tends to
drop--amongst the smart ones anyway--that the protagonists
are actually saying broadly compatible things.
|